[Paranoia] unable to rip some audio cds that play without error
richardm
rjmnook at gmail.com
Sat Aug 29 09:16:13 PDT 2015
Here are more details:
I have a box set of 16 CDs - Myaskovsky Symphonies complete. CD8 and
CD9 won't rip the last track without uncorrectable errors.
Here's the output from ripping CD9 using cdparanoia with default options:
cdparanoia -B 1-
cdparanoia III release 10.2 (September 11, 2008)
Ripping from sector 0 (track 1 [0:00.00])
to sector 333080 (track 6 [7:29.00])
outputting to track01.cdda.wav
(== PROGRESS == [ | 053850 00 ] == :^D * ==)
outputting to track02.cdda.wav
(== PROGRESS == [ | 120076 00 ] == :^D * ==)
outputting to track03.cdda.wav
(== PROGRESS == [ | 175427 00 ] == :^D * ==)
outputting to track04.cdda.wav
(== PROGRESS == [ + | 233778 00 ] == :^D * ==)
outputting to track05.cdda.wav
(== PROGRESS == [ +> | 238582 00 ] == :-P 0
==) scsi_read error: sector=239207 length=27 retry=0
Sense key: 3 ASC: 11 ASCQ: 5
Transport error: Medium reading data from medium
System error: Input/output error
(== PROGRESS == [ +e ++ | 299404 00 ] == :^D * ==)
outputting to track06.cdda.wav
(== PROGRESS == [+ > | 302658 00 ] == :-)
==) scsi_read error: sector=303418 length=27 retry=0
Sense key: 3 ASC: 11 ASCQ: 5
Transport error: Medium reading data from medium
System error: Input/output error
(== PROGRESS == [+ e> | 302875 00 ] == :-P .
==) scsi_read error: sector=303950 length=27 retry=0
Sense key: 3 ASC: 11 ASCQ: 5
Transport error: Medium reading data from medium
System error: Input/output error
scsi_read error: sector=303950 length=13 retry=1
Sense key: 3 ASC: 11 ASCQ: 5
Transport error: Medium reading data from medium
System error: Input/output error
scsi_read error: sector=303950 length=6 retry=2
Sense key: 3 ASC: 11 ASCQ: 5
Transport error: Medium reading data from medium
System error: Input/output error
(== PROGRESS == [+ e> | 302875 00 ] == :-0 o
==) scsi_read error: sector=303977 length=27 retry=0
Sense key: 3 ASC: 11 ASCQ: 5
Transport error: Medium reading data from medium
System error: Input/output error
scsi_read error: sector=303977 length=13 retry=1
Sense key: 3 ASC: 11 ASCQ: 5
Transport error: Medium reading data from medium
System error: Input/output error
(== PROGRESS == [+ e> | 303398 00 ] == :-0 .
==) scsi_read error: sector=303936 length=27 retry=0
Sense key: 3 ASC: 11 ASCQ: 5
Transport error: Medium reading data from medium
System error: Input/output error
(== PROGRESS == [+ e> | 303398 00 ] == :-0
==) ^C
Using cdda2wav for track 6 the best result I can achieve is 58% before
an unrecoverable error. I have to set the speed to 2x. 1x doesn't do as
well. Here's the output from cdda2wav:
cdda2wav -D=6,0,0 -O=wav -t 6+6 -S 2 -v all
WARNING: the deprecated pseudo SCSI syntax found as device specification.
Support for that may cease in the future versions of wodim. For now,
the device will be mapped to a block device file where possible.
Run "wodim --devices" for details.
Type: ROM, Vendor 'SONY ' Model 'CDRW/DVD CRX830E' Revision 'KDKB'
MMC+CDDA
536576 bytes buffer memory requested, 4 buffers, 52 sectors
#icedax version 1.1.11, real time sched., soundcard, libparanoia support
AUDIOtrack pre-emphasis copy-permitted tracktype channels
1- 6 no no audio 2
Table of Contents: total tracks:6, (total time 74:01.06)
1.(11:58.01), 2.(14:43.01), 3.(12:18.01), 4.(12:58.01), 5.(14:35.01),
6.( 7:29.01)
Table of Contents: starting sectors
1.( 0), 2.( 53851), 3.( 120077), 4.( 175428), 5.( 233779),
6.( 299405), lead-out( 333081)
CDINDEX discid: nYt3EDqSGcEE84wq_Md7GwIVvso-
CDDB discid: 0x46115906
CD-Text: not detected
CD-Extra: not detected
Media catalog number: 0825646968985
T: 1 ISRC: FR-42W-06-02067
T: 2 ISRC: FR-42W-06-02068
T: 3 ISRC: FR-42W-06-02069
T: 4 ISRC: FR-42W-06-02070
T: 5 ISRC: FR-42W-06-02071
T: 6 ISRC: FR-42W-06-02072
index scan: 6...
samplefile size will be 79205996 bytes.
recording 449.0133 seconds stereo with 16 bits @ 44100.0 Hz ->'audio'...
cdda2wav: Operation not permitted. cannot set posix realtime scheduling
policy
percent_done:
58%Errno: 5 (Input/output error), ReadCD MMC 12 scsi sendcmd: no error
CDB: BE 04 00 04 DF 25 00 00 34 10 00 00
status: 0x2 (CHECK CONDITION)
Sense Bytes: 70 00 03 00 00 00 00 0A 00 00 00 00 11 05 00 00
Sense Key: 0x3 Medium Error, Segment 0
Sense Code: 0x11 Qual 0x05 (l-ec uncorrectable error) Fru 0x0
Sense flags: Blk 0 (not valid)
resid: 117600
cmd finished after 6.829s timeout 60s
59%^C
W Child exited with 2
I'm certain CDs 8 and 9 are off-spec in some way, but what is find hard
to explain is why a very cheap music center will play track6 without any
audible glitch. Is there some fundamental difference in the way the data
is accessed in an audio-only application which can't be replicated on a
computer?
If I set speed down to 2x or 1x then cdparanoia barely gets through 25%
of track 6 before hanging up on retires.
The rest of the set of 16 CDs rips fine.
Not been able to try EAC - don't have a windows machine.
If I can find one, I'd buy an external true CD-ROM drive and try that -
do they exist any more?
Richard
On 28/08/15 22:26, Glenn Golden wrote:
> richardm <rjmnook at gmail.com> [2015-08-28 18:09:31 +0100]:
>> I have a few audio CDs that refuse to be ripped by cdparanoia. It's
>> usually the last track that causes the problem.
>>
> Can you be more specific about what you mean by "usually"? For example,
> suppose you attempt to rip one particular problematic CD multiple times,
> keeping everything else the same (i.e., same hardware, all the same cdparanoia
> parameters, etc.) Does the ripping consistently fail on a specific track(s)
> for that particular CD? Are the track(s) other than the problematic one(s)
> ripped ok? If you can supply full detail on what happens in this multiple-
> rip case of a single CD, it may help to narrow down the possibilities.
--
Regards,
Richard J Moore
sent from my Linux device
More information about the Paranoia
mailing list